How Time in Nature Boosts Mental Health and Reduces Stress

In 2007, the Writers Guild of America (WGA) strike brought Hollywood to a standstill. Scripted television shows went dark, production schedules were thrown into chaos, and viewers were left with a massive entertainment void. Yet, amid the crisis, one genre not only survived but thrived—reality TV. Shows like Survivor, Big Brother, and The Amazing Race saw a surge in popularity, as networks scrambled to fill the content gap left by scripted series.

Fast forward to 2024, and things look different. Reality TV, once seen as an indomitable force in entertainment, seems to be struggling. Viewership is down, new formats are floundering, and long-running franchises are losing their spark. Why has a genre that thrived during the previous strike faltered this time around?

The Changing Landscape of Entertainment

One of the biggest differences between 2007 and 2024 is the way audiences consume content. In 2007, traditional network television was still king, and reality TV provided an easy-to-produce, unscripted alternative to keep viewers engaged. But in 2024, the entertainment landscape has radically shifted. Streaming services, on-demand content, and social media platforms dominate the scene, offering viewers endless choices beyond what’s available on cable or network TV.

Reality TV Fatigue

Another factor contributing to the decline of reality TV in 2024 is simple burnout. The genre has been oversaturated for years, with countless iterations of talent competitions, dating shows, and survival challenges crowding the airwaves. What once felt fresh and exciting has become formulaic and repetitive. New reality concepts struggle to break through the noise, while older shows like The Bachelor and Keeping Up with the Kardashians have either ended or seen viewership dwindle.

The rise of social media influencers and YouTube personalities has also blurred the lines of “reality” entertainment. Platforms like Instagram and TikTok offer users a more personal, unfiltered view into people’s lives—often with more authenticity than heavily produced reality TV. For a generation raised on short-form, user-generated content.

The Rise of Competition: Docuseries and High-Quality Productions

Another genre is also encroaching on reality TV’s space—docuseries. With true crime, investigative documentaries, and high-quality, multi-part series taking center stage, viewers are flocking to well-researched, deeply engaging nonfiction stories. These docuseries often provide more substance than reality TV, with compelling narratives that feel more authentic and educational. Streaming platforms are investing heavily in this content, attracting viewers who might have previously tuned into reality TV for an entertaining escape.

Ironically, the ongoing 2024 writers strike may have hurt reality TV more than it helped this time around. While it once provided an opportunity for unscripted content to dominate, today’s strike has caused uncertainty across the entire entertainment industry. Even though reality TV is unscripted, many of these shows rely heavily on behind-the-scenes writing teams for story shaping, post-production edits, and narrative development. With production delays and fewer resources, the quality of reality programming has suffered.

In addition, networks and streaming platforms are less dependent on traditional reality content to fill gaps, thanks to their vast libraries of on-demand content and international shows, which can be quickly dubbed or subtitled.

Reality TV isn’t dead—it’s evolving. While the traditional model is hurting, we may see a new era of innovation within the genre. Producers will need to get more creative, offering new formats, interactive elements, or integrating technology like virtual reality to engage audiences. Shorter, punchier series designed for streaming platforms or new niche reality shows could help revive interest.

Ultimately, reality TV’s struggles in 2024 reflect broader changes in how we consume entertainment. The genre that once thrived during a content drought in 2007 is now facing stiff competition from a wide array of engaging, on-demand alternatives. To survive, reality TV will have to adapt to this new digital-first landscape.

Viewers now expect more curated, higher-quality content than ever before. Streaming giants like Netflix, Amazon Prime, and Disney+ offer highly produced series with cinematic storytelling, making traditional reality TV look cheap by comparison. Furthermore, streaming platforms have dipped into the reality genre themselves, but with more focused, niche offerings like The Circle or Love Is Blind. These shows cater to specific audiences and thrive on the binge-watching format, leaving older reality shows struggling to maintain weekly viewer engagement.

Perhaps one of the biggest shifts impacting reality TV is the rise of social media and influencer culture. Platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube offer a more authentic and unfiltered look into people’s lives than traditional reality shows. Influencers, with their real-time interactions and behind-the-scenes content, have become the new reality stars. The constant flow of content from influencers feels more personal and less produced, which resonates with today’s audiences.

Reality TV’s original appeal came from offering viewers a peek behind the curtain of real life. But in 2024, social media has democratized this concept. Now, anyone with a smartphone can share their life, making it harder for reality TV shows to maintain the same level of intrigue.

People ignore design that ignores people. Good design is all about making other designers feel like idiots because that idea wasn’t theirs. Design is the conscious effort to impose a meaningful order.

Andrew Bennett

Furthermore, streaming platforms have dipped into the reality genre themselves, but with more focused, niche offerings like The Circle or Love Is Blind. These shows cater to specific audiences and thrive on the binge-watching format, leaving older reality shows struggling to maintain weekly viewer engagement.

Platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube offer a more authentic and unfiltered look into people’s lives than traditional reality shows. Influencers, with their real-time interactions and behind-the-scenes content, have become the new reality stars. The constant flow of content from influencers feels more personal and less produced, which resonates with today’s audiences.

Reality TV’s original appeal came from offering viewers a peek behind the curtain of real life. But in 2024, social media has democratized this concept. Now, anyone with a smartphone can share their life, making it harder for reality TV shows to maintain the same level of intrigue.

The Impact of the 2024 Writers Strike

Ironically, the ongoing 2024 writers strike may have hurt reality TV more than it helped this time around. While it once provided an opportunity for unscripted content to dominate, today’s strike has caused uncertainty across the entire entertainment industry. Even though reality TV is unscripted, many of these shows rely heavily on behind-the-scenes writing teams for story shaping, post-production edits, and narrative development. With production delays and fewer resources, the quality of reality programming has suffered.

Unlike 2007, when reality TV became a go-to solution for content-hungry networks, today’s television executives have more options. Streaming platforms, vast libraries of pre-existing content, and the ability to pull in international series have reduced the reliance on hastily produced reality shows to fill programming gaps. The 2024 strike has affected reality TV’s ecosystem in ways that weren’t as pronounced during the 2007 strike, leaving the genre exposed.